Define who can approve a campaign and who only needs to advise
Prepared with AI assistance by Alactic Editorial. Examples identified as hypothetical are illustrative, not customer results.
A campaign brief can have everyone’s comments and still have nobody’s approval. Sales wants a stronger offer, operations questions capacity, and a subject expert suggests a different audience. The campaign owner keeps revising because each comment appears to carry the same authority.
The fix is to assign one accountable approver for each decision issue, name the people who must be consulted, and specify where unresolved objections go. Advisers supply evidence and recommendations; approvers accept or reject a defined decision within their remit. Neither role should acquire an informal veto simply by remaining dissatisfied.
Put these responsibilities inside the campaign brief before broad review begins. The worked example below provides a filled decision-rights table you can adapt, along with rules for deadlines, changes, and escalation. This is a human operating agreement, not a specification for software permissions or automated approvals.
1. Divide approval into decisions, not departments
“Marketing, sales, and operations must approve” sounds inclusive but leaves the difficult questions unanswered. Can sales reject the campaign objective? Can marketing commit delivery capacity? Does operations have authority over the wording of a headline?
Start with the issues that require distinct judgment:
- Objective: What result is the campaign intended to produce, and what trade-off is acceptable?
- Offer: What exactly is being promised, to whom, and on what terms?
- Operational commitments: Can the business fulfil the promises and handle the expected response?
- Scope changes: Which proposed revisions alter the approved audience, resources, timing, or promise?
- Final readiness: Is the agreed version complete and supported by the required decisions?
Assign authority to each issue rather than giving a department general approval over the campaign. One person may own several issues in a small team. What matters is that they know which decision they are making and which decisions belong elsewhere.
Make the boundary explicit. An operations approver can reject an unsupported response-time commitment. That does not automatically give them authority to replace the campaign objective. A campaign owner can coordinate the work without being entitled to overrule either decision.
2. Separate approval, consultation, and notification
Use three participation labels in the brief. Avoid a vague category such as “reviewer” that lets each participant interpret their own authority.
- Approver: Gives an explicit decision on an assigned issue. Approval may be withheld when the stated criteria are not met.
- Consulted adviser: Supplies expertise, identifies risks, and recommends changes by a stated deadline. Their agreement is not required unless the issue is reassigned through the escalation route.
- Informed participant: Receives the decision or approved brief so they can prepare downstream work. No response is required.
Consultation must still be meaningful. Ask a subject expert a specific question, such as whether the offer description accurately represents the service, rather than requesting unspecified “thoughts.” Give them the relevant version and enough time to examine it.
The approver should record how material advice was handled: adopted, addressed another way, or declined with a reason. This prevents consultation from becoming a ceremonial invitation while preserving the difference between expertise and decision authority.
Silence is not approval. A missed consultation deadline can allow a decision to proceed if the agreed process permits it and required evidence is available. A missing approval requires a named substitute, escalation, or a hold.
3. Use a filled decision-rights table in the brief
Fictional worked example: A business-services team is preparing a campaign offering existing customers an account-review session. All roles, quantities, timings, and conditions below are hypothetical. The campaign aims to generate 30 qualified bookings from an initial audience of 200 eligible customers, with no more than 10 sessions available each week.
The following is a filled, row-by-row decision-rights table. Each entry identifies the decision, its owner, the evidence required, and the route for disagreement. The thresholds are example design choices, not universal rules.
Objective
- Decision: Prioritise qualified account-review bookings rather than total responses.
- Approver: Marketing lead.
- Consulted: Sales lead on qualification criteria; analyst on whether the result can be measured.
- Approval evidence: Brief names the target of 30 qualified bookings and defines a qualified booking as an existing customer with an identified review need who accepts a session.
- Boundary: Sales advises on qualification but cannot independently replace the objective with immediate revenue.
- Deadline and escalation: Decision recorded Monday by noon; unresolved objective disputes go to the campaign sponsor.
Offer
- Decision: Offer one account-review session, with no discount or guaranteed commercial result.
- Approver: Commercial lead.
- Consulted: Service specialist on accuracy; sales lead on likely customer questions.
- Approval evidence: Exact offer wording, eligibility conditions, and exclusions are attached to the brief.
- Boundary: Copy suggestions are advisory unless they change the promise, eligibility, or terms.
- Deadline and escalation: Decision recorded Monday by 4 p.m.; unresolved promise or terms disputes go to the campaign sponsor with the operations lead consulted.
Operational commitments
- Decision: Make 10 sessions available each week and respond to booking requests within two business days.
- Approver: Operations lead.
- Consulted: Scheduling coordinator and customer-support lead.
- Approval evidence: Named session owners, available appointment slots, a request-handling owner, and a fallback for excess demand.
- Boundary: No other approver may substitute an unsupported capacity assumption for this commitment.
- Deadline and escalation: Decision recorded Tuesday by noon; capacity conflicts go to the sponsor to choose additional resources, a smaller audience, revised timing, or a hold.
Scope changes
- Decision: Accept or reject changes to the approved baseline.
- Approver: Campaign owner for wording-only changes; campaign sponsor for changes to audience, launch date, or resource allocation.
- Consulted: The issue owner whose approved decision would be affected.
- Approval evidence: A change note showing the previous version, proposed revision, reason, and affected commitments.
- Boundary: Any change to the offer or operational promise also requires renewed approval from its issue owner. The sponsor does not silently inherit that authority.
- Deadline and escalation: Classify each change before editing the baseline; disputed classifications go to the sponsor before work proceeds.
Final readiness
- Decision: Declare the campaign brief ready for the separately authorised launch process.
- Approver: Campaign owner.
- Consulted: Delivery coordinator, sales lead, and customer-support lead.
- Approval evidence: Matching version references, explicit issue approvals, confirmed handoffs, and no unresolved hold conditions.
- Boundary: Readiness approval cannot waive a missing offer or capacity approval. It does not itself execute the campaign.
- Deadline and escalation: Readiness decision Wednesday by noon; missing decisions go to the named deputy or sponsor, and the campaign remains on hold if required approval is absent.
Attach the actual names and deputies when using this artifact. A role label helps define durable responsibility, but an unnamed role cannot answer a time-sensitive decision request.
4. Give objections a format that leads to a decision
A comment such as “I’m not comfortable with this” is a reason to investigate, not a usable decision record. Ask the contributor to identify the affected issue, the evidence, the likely consequence, and the requested change.
In the fictional example, an actionable objection would read: “Operational commitments: only six session slots are currently staffed next week, rather than the approved ten. Reduce the first audience batch or confirm additional staffing before readiness approval.”
That objection points to a testable gap. Compare it with “The campaign feels too ambitious,” which leaves the owner guessing what would resolve the concern.
The campaign owner should route comments into three categories:
- Required decision gap: Evidence or approval required by the brief is missing. Hold the affected decision.
- Material challenge: New information could invalidate an approved assumption. Reopen the relevant issue for its approver.
- Preference: A suggested alternative that does not breach an agreed criterion. The assigned approver may accept or decline it.
An adviser can discover a genuine blocker. Their consultation status does not make the evidence optional. Equally, describing a preference as a risk should not automatically create veto power.
5. Escalate choices, not whole comment threads
Escalation should resolve a particular decision, not invite a more senior person to review the entire campaign from scratch.
For an unresolved objection, send a short decision note containing:
- The issue and the current approver.
- The disputed fact, assumption, or trade-off.
- The options, including a hold where appropriate.
- The recommendation and consequences of each option.
- The decision needed, its deadline, and who will record it.
In the fictional capacity dispute, the sponsor could choose to fund additional staffing, reduce the audience, or move the launch date. The sponsor cannot make unavailable appointment slots exist merely by accepting the risk. Operations must still confirm what it can deliver under the selected option.
Name the escalation authority and deputy before a dispute occurs. If neither is available, use the brief’s hold rule rather than searching for someone willing to approve. For issues outside the team’s competence, seek the appropriate specialist input rather than asking the campaign sponsor to improvise an answer.
6. Reopen only the decisions a change actually affects
A common failure is treating every revision as either harmless or a reason to restart all approvals. Both extremes waste time.
Use an approved baseline with a version reference. For each proposed change, ask whether it alters an assumption another approver relied on. A punctuation correction normally does not. Adding customers to the audience may affect eligibility, capacity, and timing even when the message stays identical.
In the fictional campaign, changing “account review” to a different phrase might be a wording decision if the meaning remains unchanged. Adding a promise to identify savings would change the offer and require renewed commercial approval. Doubling the audience would reopen operational capacity and the sponsor’s scope decision.
Record the affected decisions and preserve unaffected approvals. If the impact is uncertain, ask the relevant issue owner to classify it before proceeding. This adds a small check without turning every edit into a full review cycle.
7. Recover when authority is missing or overlapping
Two people claim final authority. Ask the sponsor to resolve the ownership conflict before the substantive dispute. Split distinct decisions where possible: one person owns the offer; another owns the capacity needed to fulfil it. Do not use joint approval as a permanent substitute for clear boundaries.
An approver is unavailable. Use a deputy with explicitly delegated authority. If none exists, escalate or hold. A campaign owner should not sign on someone’s behalf merely to protect the schedule.
A late objection reveals new evidence. Reopen the affected issue even if the consultation deadline has passed. Deadlines control review effort; they do not make contradictory facts disappear.
A late objection repeats a settled preference. Refer to the recorded decision and rationale. Reopening it requires a changed assumption, new evidence, or an authorised change request—not simply continued disagreement.
One approver becomes a bottleneck. Examine whether they truly need to own every issue. Delegate bounded decisions and improve the evidence package rather than making approvals implicit. Fewer approvers can shorten coordination, but concentrating unrelated authority can hide weak decisions.
8. Test the agreement on the next campaign
Before the next brief goes out for review, spend one short working session filling the five decision rows. Name each approver and deputy, specify the evidence they need, and agree on consultation deadlines and escalation destinations.
Then ask each participant to answer two questions: “What can you decide?” and “What happens if your recommendation is not accepted?” Any inconsistent answers expose ambiguity worth fixing before review begins.
Track a small set of observable outcomes for that campaign:
- Time from a complete decision request to an explicit answer.
- Number of missing approvals at the readiness checkpoint.
- Number of decisions reopened, separated into new evidence, scope changes, and repeated preferences.
- Number of escalations caused by unclear ownership rather than a genuine trade-off.
Do not treat speed alone as success. A fast approval followed by an unfulfillable promise is a failed decision. The practical test is whether the team can identify who decided each material issue, what evidence supported it, and where any unresolved objection went.
Put the next conversation to work.
Explore Alactic Communications for WhatsApp conversations, campaigns and AI-assisted workflows. Choose the product and plan that fit your team.
Explore Communications